Most of my working week is spent being turned down.
Not in any dramatic way. A journalist reads the first line of a pitch, decides it isn’t for them, and moves on to the next email. It happens to every PR adviser, every day, and if rejection bothered me I’d have left this business a long time ago.
What I’ve learned is that a no is rarely the problem. A no tells you something.
What a no is telling you
When an editor turns a story down, it usually comes down to one of three things. The story wasn’t sharp enough. The timing was wrong. Or it went to the wrong desk.
Each of those can be fixed. A story that wasn’t sharp enough needs a better reason to run today: a number, a person, a consequence for the reader. A story with the wrong timing can wait for the moment the news turns towards it. And a story on the wrong desk often just needs the right journalist, because the business editor and the health correspondent are reading for different things.
For me, the worst thing you can do with a no is send the same pitch somewhere else unchanged. You’ve been handed feedback. Use it.
What silence is telling you
Silence is harder. Nobody tells you why, so you have to work it out yourself.
Sometimes the email was buried. More often, the first line didn’t earn the second. My sense is that silence is usually a signal about the story, not the journalist. So before chasing, I go back to the pitch and ask what an editor would ask: why this, why now, why my readers? If I can’t answer that in a sentence, the problem is mine to fix.
Why this matters if you’re the client
If you’re hiring a PR adviser, ask them what happens when the answer is no.
Anyone can send a press release. The real value is knowing what to do when it doesn’t land.
Sometimes that means finding a better angle. Sometimes it means waiting for the right moment. And sometimes it means telling a client that the story simply isn’t strong enough.
That’s not failure. That’s judgement.
I’ve always thought the best leaders handle rejection in much the same way. They don’t take it personally, but they don’t ignore what it tells them either.
Don’t waste a no.
